The decline of the art critic reflects a major shift from expert-driven value to market- and audience-driven value. Critics once shaped public taste through long-form essays and deep analysis, helping define what was culturally significant. But that influence depended on attention, patience, and trust in expertise—three things that are increasingly scarce in today’s digital world.

Now, short-form content dominates. Reels, TikToks, and quick visuals reach buyers faster and more effectively than lengthy reviews ever could. People scroll more than they read, and the artist who can communicate their vision clearly and compellingly in a few seconds often outperforms the one waiting on critical acclaim.

In this landscape, social proof carries more weight than a critic’s endorsement. Testimonials, follower counts, and audience engagement now shape perception and drive sales. A strong online presence isn’t just helpful—it’s essential. And for artists selling online, real-world validation from past buyers builds the kind of trust that used to come from galleries and institutions.

Sure, the upper-tier art world still leans on legacy systems—critics, curators, and exclusive circles. But at Picture It, we believe a new era has begun - one where the artist is also the entrepreneur. With the right tools, an online store, and a story worth telling, artists can take control of their own success. You don’t need permission to build a career in art—you just need your own platform and the courage to own it.

‍